Balog: Difference between revisions

2,071 bytes added ,  18 October 2023
m
 
Line 149: Line 149:


==Morphology==
==Morphology==
In the Balog's own grammatical tradition, three parts of speech are recognised:
* '''''Xam''''' "meat"
* '''''Mološ''''' "sauce" 
* '''''Tlaz''''' "spice"
According to grammatical descriptions of Balog in Balog, '''''xam''''' or "meat words" are those that are integral to the meaning of a sentence. These are the content words or ''contentives''. '''''Mološ''''' or "sauce words" glue the meat words together and form grammatically correct sentences. These are termed 'linkers'. '''''Tlaz''''' or "spice words" provide finer shades of meaning and bring greater context and clarity to the whole utterance, although it is often possible to omit them. These are called 'particles' in English.
===Contentives (''Xam'')===
===Contentives (''Xam'')===
There is only one class of content word in Balog. These form the equivalent of verbs, nouns, adjectives and pronouns in other languages. Words of this lexical category cannot be sorted into separate discrete classes of nouns, verbs etc. using syntax or morphology. With few exceptions, each contentive exhibits complete bidirectional subject-predicate flexibility, meaning they can be used in predicates ("verbally") or be preceded by a subject clitic in order to be used ("nominally") as the subject of a clause without any irregular changes in form or meaning. This class of words in Balog is refered to as "contentives".
There is only one class of content word in Balog. These form the equivalent of verbs, nouns, adjectives and pronouns in other languages. Words of this lexical category cannot be sorted into separate discrete classes of nouns, verbs etc. using syntax or morphology. With few exceptions, each contentive exhibits complete bidirectional subject-predicate flexibility, meaning they can be used in predicates ("verbally") or be preceded by a subject clitic in order to be used ("nominally") as the subject of a clause without any irregular changes in form or meaning. This class of words in Balog is refered to as "contentives".
Line 192: Line 200:
däžib      | fallen tree, log|                                                          XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXxxxxx</pre>
däžib      | fallen tree, log|                                                          XXXXXXXXXXXXXXXxxxxx</pre>


===Adverbs===
===Particles===
Adverbs modify verbs to give them new shades of meaning. The vast majority of adverbs are very short, particle-like words. For example, adverbs indicating tense and aspect optionally stand before a verb and give temporal information about it. These are not restricted to use with semantically verbal verbs, nor are they restricted to syntactic positions within a predicate as subject phrases themselves consist of  
Particles modify contentives to give them new shades of meaning. The vast majority of particles are very short words. For example, particles indicating tense and aspect optionally stand before a contentive and give temporal information about it. These are not restricted to use with semantically verbal contentives, nor are they restricted to syntactic positions within a predicate as subject phrases themselves consist of a subject clitic followed by a contentive (phrase).


In the following example, the imperfective particle '''''hi''''' indicates that the action of dying is not spoken about as a completed whole, but, rather, an action seen from the middle, thus "is dying" (or according to context, "was dying" etc.). The past tense particle '''''do''''' appears before '''''garag''''' "be neighbour" to indicate "be one who was a neighbour", thus "former neighbour" in the translation.  
In the following example, the continuous particle '''''hi''''' indicates that the action of dying is not spoken about as a completed whole, but, rather, an action seen from the middle, thus "is dying" (or according to context, "was dying" etc.). The past tense particle '''''do''''' appears before '''''garag''''' "be neighbour" to indicate "be one who was a neighbour", thus "former neighbour" in the translation.  


: {|  
: {|  
Line 205: Line 213:
| <span style="color:#0000FF">'''hi'''</span> || '''zowak''' || '''aqa(ː)-''' || '''<span style="color:#0000FF">do</span>''' || '''garag''' || '''we(ː)-''' || '''ni(ː)-''' || '''ž'''
| <span style="color:#0000FF">'''hi'''</span> || '''zowak''' || '''aqa(ː)-''' || '''<span style="color:#0000FF">do</span>''' || '''garag''' || '''we(ː)-''' || '''ni(ː)-''' || '''ž'''
|-
|-
| <span style="color:#0000FF">IPFV</span> || die.of.protracted.illness || SPEC(B)- || <span style="color:#0000FF">PST</span> || neighbour || ESS- || GEN- || 1S
| <span style="color:#0000FF">IPFV</span> || die.of.protracted.illness || SPEC(B)- || <span style="color:#0000FF">PST</span> || Garag || ESS- || GEN- || 1S
|-
|-
| colspan="8" | "A <span style="color:#0000FF">former</span> neighbour of mine <span style="color:#0000FF">is</span> dy<span style="color:#0000FF">ing</span> (of a protracted illness)."
| colspan="8" | "A <span style="color:#0000FF">former</span> garag of mine <span style="color:#0000FF">is</span> dy<span style="color:#0000FF">ing</span> (of a protracted illness)."
|}
|}


===Syntactic Clitics===  
===Linkers===  
Syntactic clitics are morphemes that attach to the first word of a verb phrase in order to subordinate them in some manner into another verb phrase. Syntactic clitics include the archiphoneme /ː/, which lengthens the clitic's vowel when the following verb phrase consists of only a consonant and otherwise geminates the following consonant.
Linkers are morphemes that attach to the first word of a contentive phrase in order to coordinate them with or subordinate them in some manner into another contentive phrase. Clitic linkers include the archiphoneme /ː/, which lengthens the clitic's vowel when the rest of the clause consists of only a single consonant and otherwise geminates the following consonant.


====Essive====
====Essive====
The essive or equative clitic '''''we(:)-''''' introduces a verb phrase that modifies its preceding head in a strict, additive manner. It is frequently translated into English by means of a relative pronoun.
The essive or equative clitic '''''we(:)-''''' introduces a contentive phrase that modifies its preceding head in a strict, additive manner. It is frequently translated into English by means of a relative pronoun.


: {|  
: {|  
Line 222: Line 230:
| '''aqa(:) || '''balog''' || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''we(:)-'''</span> || '''ŋaž'''  
| '''aqa(:) || '''balog''' || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''we(:)-'''</span> || '''ŋaž'''  
|-
|-
| SPEC(b) || be.Balog || <span style="color:#0000FF">ESS-</span> || be.tall
| SPEC.R2 || be.Balog || <span style="color:#0000FF">ESS-</span> || be.tall
|-
|-
| colspan="4" | "a tall Balog"
| colspan="4" | "a tall Balog"
Line 233: Line 241:
| '''i(:) || '''džeb''' || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''we(:)-'''</span> || '''šwaŋ'''  
| '''i(:) || '''džeb''' || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''we(:)-'''</span> || '''šwaŋ'''  
|-
|-
| SPEC(b) || be.slave|| <span style="color:#0000FF">ESS-</span> || execute.PRF.PASS
| SPEC.R5 || be.slave|| <span style="color:#0000FF">ESS-</span> || execute.PRF.PASS
|-
|-
| colspan="4" | "the slave who has been executed"
| colspan="4" | "the slave who has been executed"
Line 240: Line 248:
: {|  
: {|  
|-  
|-  
| colspan="4" | '''''iddemeg webbad'''''
| colspan="4" | '''''iddemeg weddag'''''
|-
|-
| '''i(:)- || '''demeg''' || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''we(:)-'''</span> || '''bad'''  
| '''i(:)- || '''demeg''' || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''we(:)-'''</span> || '''dag'''  
|-
|-
| DEF(e) || be.book || <span style="color:#0000FF">ESS-</span> || be.big
| DEF.R5 || be.book || <span style="color:#0000FF">ESS-</span> || be.big
|-
|-
| colspan="4" | "the big book"
| colspan="4" | "the big book"
Line 255: Line 263:
| '''eqe(:)- || '''ŋal''' || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''we(:)-'''</span> || '''louh'''  
| '''eqe(:)- || '''ŋal''' || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''we(:)-'''</span> || '''louh'''  
|-
|-
| SPEC(d) || use.leg || <span style="color:#0000FF">ESS-</span> || sleep
| SPEC.R4 || use.leg || <span style="color:#0000FF">ESS-</span> || sleep
|-
|-
| colspan="4" | "a sleepwalker", "a walker who sleeps"
| colspan="4" | "a sleepwalker", "a walker who sleeps"
Line 283: Line 291:


====Subject Clitics====
====Subject Clitics====
Subject clitics appear at the beginning of every phrase denoting a grammatical subject. They indicate not only that the following base phrase is the subject of the preceding predicate but also convey information about '''definiteness''' (whether the addressee is expected to know which exact entity), '''specificity''' (whether the speaker knows which exact entity) and an inflectional dimension integral to Balog called ''status'', described below.
''Subject clitics'' or ''subjectifiers'' appear at the beginning of every phrase denoting a grammatical subject. They indicate not only that the following base phrase is the subject of the preceding predicate but also convey information about '''definiteness''' (whether the addressee is expected to know which exact entity), '''specificity''' (whether the speaker knows which exact entity) and an inflectional dimension integral to Balog called ''rank'', described below.  
 
In everyday use, when not speaking to a much higher ranked individual, the definite forms are frequently used even for specific indefinite referents, with the specific, indefinite forms with <q> being more emphatically indefinite, representing a marked indication to the listener that they are not expected to know the identity of the referent. When speaking to higher ranked individuals, failure to use the indefinite specific forms when needed is seen as an affront to the hierarchy of respect as it effectively eliminates any indication of the listener's knowledge of the situation.


{| class="wikitable" style="text-align: center"
{| class="wikitable" style="text-align: center"
Line 295: Line 301:
|-
|-
! "Powerful" !! (A)  
! "Powerful" !! (A)  
| <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''u(:)-'''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''uqu(:)-'''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''uhu(:)-'''''</span> || —
| <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''uu='''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''uquu='''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''uhuu='''''</span> || —
|-
|-
! "Dominant" !! (B)
! "Dominant" !! (B)
| <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''a(:)-'''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''aqa(:)-'''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''aha(:)-'''''</span> || —
| <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''aa='''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''aqaa='''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''ahaa='''''</span> || —
|-
|-
! "Intermediate" !! (C)
! "Intermediate" !! (C)
| <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''o(:)-'''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''oqo(:)-'''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''oho(:)-'''''</span> || —
| <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''oo='''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''oqoo=''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''ohoo='''''</span> || —
|-
|-
! "Subordinate" !! (D)
! "Subordinate" !! (D)
| <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''e(:)-'''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''eqe(:)-'''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''ehe(:)-'''''</span> || —
| <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''ee='''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''eqee='''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''ehee='''''</span> || —
|-
|-
! "Powerless" !! (E)
! "Powerless" !! (E)
| <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''i(:)-'''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''iqi(:)-'''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''ihi(:)-'''''</span> || —
| <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''ii='''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''iqii='''''</span> || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''ihii='''''</span> || —
|-
|-
! "Unknown, animate"  !! (ANIM)
! "Unknown, animate"  !! (ANIM)
| — || — || — || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''ü(:)-'''''</span>
| — || — || — || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''üü='''''</span>
|-
|-
! "Unknown, inanimate"  !! (INAN)
! "Unknown, inanimate"  !! (INAN)
| — || — || — || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''ai(:)-'''''</span>
| — || — || — || <span style="color:#0000FF">'''''aii='''''</span>
|-
|-
! colspan="6" | <small>Propositions</small>
! colspan="6" | <small>Propositions</small>
Line 321: Line 327:
|}
|}


Due to the rarity of use of the ranked nonspecific subject clitics, which are chiefly replaced by the unranked, unknown subject clitics, the non-specific subject clitics, with /h/, are increasingly being used as allomorphs of the specific indefinite subject clitics with /ʔ/, being more frequently used in environments near another /ʔ/. For example, '''''luq eqeggitsag''''' 'a Balog's assistant is present' may also be pronounced as '''''luq eheggitsag''''' with no change in meaning. When speaking of the desire of a non-specific non-Balog man's presence, the unknown animate subject clitic will be used: '''''he luq eheggitsag''''' 'May a Balog's assistant be present.'
The above table gives the forms as expressed in old prescriptive texts in Balog. In everyday use, however, the usage of what are here termed the specific indefinite forms (with VqVV=) and the non-specific indefinite forms is different.
 
Due to the fact that non-specific referents are unknown, the ranked non-specific forms with /h/ are nowadays usually replaced by the unknown clitics '''''üü=''''' and '''''aii='''''. Formerly, the ranked forms were used in order to set the rank of an unknown entity so that it may be discussed in following sentences, however, this distinction is no longer maintained and unknown entities, unless their rank is clear from the context, are left unranked and referred to using '''''üü=''''' and '''''aii='''''. The distinction between the VqVV= forms and VhVV= forms has thus effectively been neutralised. The non-specific subject clitics of the form VhVV= are nowadays chiefly used as allomorphs of the specific indefinite subject clitics with the form VqVV=, being more frequently used in environments near another instance of /ʔ/. For example, '''''luq eqeggitsag''''' 'a Balog's assistant is present' may also be pronounced as '''''luq eheggitsag''''' with no change in meaning. When speaking of the desire of a non-specific non-Balog man's presence, the unknown animate subject clitic will be used: '''''he luq üggitsag''''' 'May a Balog's assistant be present.' Some speakers have a preference for the VhVV= forms and others for the VqVV= forms. A few speakers still abide by the old prescriptive norms, distinguishing specific from non-specific from unrankable unknown entities.
 
Furthermore, the definite forms (VV=) are frequently used even for specific indefinite referents, with the indefinite forms (VqVV= and VhVV=) being more emphatically indefinite, representing a marked indication to the listener that they are not expected to know the identity of the referent. When speaking to higher ranked individuals, failure to use the indefinite forms when needed is seen as an affront to the hierarchy of respect as it effectively eliminates any indication of the listener's knowledge of the situation.


=====Status=====
=====Rank=====
All referents are assigned a '''status''' any time they are appear as the subject of a clause. Status is not a permanent attribute of a referent but rather a context-dependent assignment within a discourse that depends on the speaker's perceived and expressed relations between the referent and other referents. When a single referent is mentioned, the status used depends only on the speaker's perception of the referent, however when there are two or more referents, statuses may be assigned that would otherwise not be used in order to differentiate between multiple referents within a discourse and rank them relative to one another.
All known referents are assigned a '''rank''' any time they are appear as the subject of a clause. Rank is not a permanent attribute of a referent but rather a context-dependent assignment within a discourse that depends on the speaker's perceived and expressed relations between the referent and other referents. When a single referent is mentioned, the rank used depends only on the speaker's perception of the referent, however when there are two or more referents, ranks may be assigned that would otherwise not be used in order to differentiate between multiple referents within a discourse in order to show a hierarchy. Rank is the chief means of anaphoric reference and even person and number marking proforms such as '''''ž''''' 'I' and '''''l''''' 'you' (singular) are frequently dropped once they have been assigned a rank.


A useful way to conceptualise the typical assignment of status is to use the question "Who would win in a physical fight?" as the deciding metric. Physically larger, stronger and more active referents are assigned a higher status than smaller, weaker referents. The highest status, A, the "powerful" status, indicated with the vowel '''u''', is an exception, dependent not only physical strength but rather social, financial or political power. A referent marked with '''u''' is not necessarily physically dominant over other referents, but a conflict with an individual could lead to more significant consequences for referents of lower status than the physical prowess of the A-statused referent alone would afford them. "Weighty" abstract concepts may sometimes be referred to with the A-status when there is no person in the discourse assigned to this status.
A useful way to conceptualise the typical assignment of rank is to use the question "Who would win in a physical fight?" as the deciding metric. Physically larger, stronger and more active referents are ranked higher than smaller, weaker referents. In some contexts, height alone has been agreed upon as the way to assign ranks. The highest rank, glossed R1, the "powerful" rank, indicated with the vowel '''u''', is a slight exception, frequently assigned to those who do not necessarily have physical strength but rather social, financial or political power. A referent marked with '''u''' is not necessarily physically dominant over other referents, but a conflict with an individual could lead to more significant consequences for referents of lower status than the physical prowess of the R1-ranked referent alone would afford them. "Weighty" or "untouchable" abstract concepts may sometimes be referred to with the U-status when there is no person in the discourse assigned to this rank. This is common with a few contentives such as '''''guwax''''' 'sun' and '''''tot''''' 'time'.
======Pronouns======
======Proforms======
{| class="wikitable" style="font-style:italic; font-weight:bold;" style="vertical-align: top;"
{| class="wikitable" style="font-style:italic; font-weight:bold;" style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="font-style:normal; font-weight:normal;" style="vertical-align: top;"
|- style="font-style:normal; font-weight:normal;" style="vertical-align: top;"
577

edits