Linguifex

User:Chrysophylax/Skājamāl/Phonology: Difference between revisions

User page Discussion

User:Chrysophylax/Skājamāl/Phonology (view source)

Revision as of 00:50, 20 May 2014

13,048 bytes removed ,  20 May 2014
m
→‎Vowels
(Created page with "===Vowels=== Proto-Germanic had four short vowels<ref>On ''i'' and ''e'' see {{harvnb|Cercignani|1979}}.</ref> five or six long vowels, and at least one "overlong" or "trimori...")
 
Line 1: Line 1:
===Vowels===
===Vowels===
Proto-Germanic had four short vowels<ref>On ''i'' and ''e'' see {{harvnb|Cercignani|1979}}.</ref> five or six long vowels, and at least one "overlong" or "trimoric" vowel. The exact phonetic quality of the vowels is uncertain.
Proto-Germanic had four short vowels<ref>On ''i'' and ''e'', five or six long vowels, and at least one "overlong" or "trimoric" vowel. The exact phonetic quality of the vowels is uncertain.


{|
{|
Line 39: Line 39:
| {{PIE|ɛːː}}
| {{PIE|ɛːː}}
|
|
| {{PIE|ɔː}}
| {{PIE|<s>ɔː</s> ↓ː}}
| {{PIE|ɔːː}}
| {{PIE|<s>ɔːː</s> ←}}
|-
|-
! [[Open vowel|Open]]
! [[Open vowel|Open]]
Line 66: Line 66:
|-
|-
! [[Close vowel|Close]]
! [[Close vowel|Close]]
| {{PIE|ĩ}}
| {{PIE|<s>ĩ</s>→iː}}
| {{PIE|ĩː}}
| {{PIE|<s>ĩː</s>←}}
|
|
| {{PIE|ũ}}
| {{PIE|<s>ũ</s>→uː}}
| {{PIE|ũː}}
| {{PIE|<s>ũː</s>←}}
|
|
|-
|-
Line 86: Line 86:
|
|
|
|
| {{PIE|ɔ̃ː}}
| {{PIE|<s>ɔ̃ː</s>→oː}}
| {{PIE|ɔ̃ːː}}
| {{PIE|<s>ɔ̃ːː</s>←}}
|-
|-
! [[Open vowel|Open]]
! [[Open vowel|Open]]
Line 93: Line 93:
|
|
|
|
| {{PIE|ɑ̃}}
| {{PIE|<s>ɑ̃</s>→aː}}
| {{PIE|ɑ̃ː}}
| {{PIE|<s>ɑ̃ː</s>←}}
|
|
|}
|}
Line 113: Line 113:
* Short: {{PIE|/ɑu/}}, {{PIE|/ɑi/}}, {{PIE|/eu/}}, {{PIE|/iu/}}
* Short: {{PIE|/ɑu/}}, {{PIE|/ɑi/}}, {{PIE|/eu/}}, {{PIE|/iu/}}
* Long: {{PIE|/ɔːu/}}, {{PIE|/ɔːi/}}, (possibly {{PIE|/ɛːu/}}, {{PIE|/ɛːi/}})
* Long: {{PIE|/ɔːu/}}, {{PIE|/ɔːi/}}, (possibly {{PIE|/ɛːu/}}, {{PIE|/ɛːi/}})
Note the change {{PIE|/e/}} > {{PIE|/i/}} before {{PIE|/i/}} or {{PIE|/j/}} in the same or following syllable. This removed {{PIE|/ei/}} (which became {{PIE|/iː/}}) but created {{PIE|/iu/}} from earlier {{PIE|/eu/}}.
Diphthongs in Proto-Germanic can also be analysed as sequences of a vowel plus an approximant, as was the case in Proto-Indo-European. This explains why {{PIE|/j/}} was not lost in *''niwjaz'' ("new"); the second element of the diphthong ''iu'' was still underlyingly a consonant and therefore the conditioning environment for the loss was not met. This is also confirmed by the fact that later in the [[West Germanic gemination]], -''wj''- is geminated to -''wwj''- in parallel with the other consonants (except {{PIE|/r/}}).
====Overlong vowels====
Proto-Germanic had two overlong or trimoraic long vowels ''ô'' {{IPA|[ɔːː]}} and ''ê'' {{IPA|[ɛːː]}}, the latter mainly in adverbs (cf. *''hwadrê'' "whereto, whither").<ref name=ringe>{{harvnb|Ringe|2006|p=295}}</ref> None of the documented languages still include such vowels. Their reconstruction is due to the [[comparative method]], particularly as a way of explaining an otherwise unpredictable two-way split of reconstructed long ''ō'' in final syllables, which unexpectedly remained long in some morphemes but shows normal shortening in others. (See below.)
Trimoraic vowels generally occurred at [[morpheme]] boundaries where a bimoraic long vowel and a short vowel in hiatus contracted, especially after the loss of an intervening [[laryngeal]] (-''VHV''-).<ref>{{cite book | first=Benjamin W. IV | last=Fortson | title=Indo-European Language and Culture: An Introduction | edition=2nd | series=Blackwell Textbooks in Linguistics | location=Global | publisher=Blackwell Publishing | year=2010 | page=342}}</ref> One example, without a laryngeal, includes the class II weak verbs (''ō''-stems) where a -''j''- was lost between vowels, so that -''ōja'' → ''ōa'' → ''ô'' (cf. *''salbōjaną'' → *''salbôną'' → Gothic ''salbōn'' "to anoint"). However, the majority occurred in word-final syllables (inflectional endings) probably because in this position the vowel could not be resyllabified.<ref>{{citation | first=T.A. | last=Hall | contribution=The Distribution of Trimoraic Syllables in German and English as Evidence for the Phonological Word | editor-first=T. A. | editor-last=Hall | editor2-first=Marzena | editor2-last=Rochoń | title=Investigations in Prosodic Phonology: The Role of the Foot and the Phonological Word | series=ZAS Papers in Linguistics 19 | year=2000 | publisher=ZAS, Zentrum für Allgemeine Sprachwissenschaft (ZAS) | location=Berlin | pages=41–90 | url=http://www.zas.gwz-berlin.de/fileadmin/material/ZASPiL_Volltexte/zp19/zaspil19-hall.pdf}}</ref> Additionally, Germanic, like Balto-Slavic, lengthened bimoraic long vowels in absolute final position, perhaps to better conform to a word's [[Prosody (linguistics)|prosodic]] template; e.g., PGmc *''arô'' "eagle" ← PIE *''h₃érō'' just as Lith ''akmuő'' "stone", OSl ''kamy'' ← *''aḱmō̃'' ← PIE *''h₂éḱmō''). Contrast:
* contraction after loss of laryngeal: gen.pl. *''wulfǫ̂'' "wolves'" ← *''wulfôn'' ← pre-Gmc *''wúlpōom'' ← PIE *''{{PIE|wĺ̥kʷoHom}}''; ō-stem nom.pl. *''-ôz'' ← pre-Gmc *''-āas'' ← PIE *''-eh₂es''.
* contraction of short vowels: a-stem nom.pl. *''wulfôz'' "wolves" ← PIE *''wĺ̥kʷoes''.
But vowels that were lengthened by laryngeals did not become overlong. Compare:
* ō-stem nom.sg. *''-ō'' ← *''-ā'' ← PIE *''{{PIE|-eh₂}}'';
* ō-stem acc.sg. *''-ǭ'' ← *''-ān'' ← *''-ām'' (by [[Stang's law]]) ← PIE *''{{PIE|-eh₂m}}'';
* ō-stem acc.pl. *''-ōz'' ← *''-āz'' ← *''-ās'' (by [[Stang's law]]) ← PIE *''{{PIE|-eh₂ns}}'';
Trimoraic vowels are distinguished from bimoraic vowels by their outcomes in attested Germanic languages: word-final trimoraic vowels remained long vowels while bimoraic vowels developed into short vowels. Older theories about the phenomenon claimed that long and overlong vowels were both long but differed in [[tone (linguistics)|tone]], i.e., ''ô'' and ''ê'' had a "circumflex" (rise-fall-rise) tone while ''ō'' and ''ē'' had an "acute" (rising) tone, much like the tones of modern Scandinavian languages,<ref>{{cite book | first=Anatoly | last=Liberman | title=Germanic Accentology | location=Minneapolis | publisher=University of Minnesota Press | year=1982 | page=140}}</ref> Baltic, and Ancient Greek, and asserted that this distinction was inherited from PIE. However, this view was abandoned since languages do not combine distinctive intonations on unstressed syllables with contrastive stress and vowel length.<ref>{{cite journal | first=Julius | last=Purczinsky | title=Proto-Indo-European Circumflex Intonation or Bisyllabicity | journal=Word | volume=44 | issue=1 | year=1993 | page=53}}</ref> Modern theories have reinterpreted overlong vowels as having superheavy syllable weight (three [[mora (linguistics)|mora]]s) and therefore greater length than ordinary long vowels.
By the end of the Proto-Germanic period, word-final long vowels were shortened to short vowels. Following that, overlong vowels were shortened to regular long vowels in all positions, merging with originally long vowels except word-finally (because of the earlier shortening), so that they remained distinct in that position. This was a late dialectal development, because the end result was not the same in all Germanic languages: word-final ''ē'' shortened to ''a'' in East and West Germanic but to ''i'' in Old Norse, and word-final ''ō'' shortened to ''a'' in Gothic but to ''o'' (probably {{IPA|[o]}}) in early North and West Germanic, with a later raising to ''u'' (the 6th century [[Salic law]] still has ''malth'''o''''' in late Frankish).
The shortened overlong vowels in final position developed as regular long vowels from that point on, including the lowering of ''ē'' to ''ā'' in North and West Germanic. The monophthongization of unstressed ''au'' in Northwest Germanic produced a phoneme which merged with this new word-final long ''ō'', while the monophthongization of unstressed ''ai'' produced a new ''ē'' which did not merge with original ''ē'', but rather with ''ē₂'', as it was not lowered to ''ā''. This split, combined with the asymmetric development in West Germanic, with ''ē'' lowering but ''ō'' raising, points to an early difference in the articulation height of the two vowels that was not present in North Germanic. It could be seen as evidence that the lowering of ''ē'' to ''ā'' began in West Germanic at a time when final vowels were still long, and spread to North Germanic through the late Germanic dialect continuum, but only reaching the latter after the vowels had already been shortened.
====ē₁ and ē₂====
''ē₂'' is uncertain as a phoneme, and only reconstructed from a small number of words; it is posited by the comparative method because whereas all provable instances of inherited (PIE) *''ē'' (PGmc. *''ē₁'') are distributed in Gothic as ''ē'' and the other Germanic languages as *''ā'',<ref>But see {{harvnb|Cercignani|1972}}</ref> all the Germanic languages agree on some occasions of ''ē'' (e.&nbsp;g., Goth./OE/ON ''hēr'' "here" ← PGmc. *''hē₂r''). Gothic makes no orthographic and therefore presumably no phonetic distinction between ''ē₁'' and ''ē₂'', but the existence of two Proto-Germanic long ''e''-like phonemes is supported by the existence of two ''e''-like [[Elder Futhark]] runes, [[Ehwaz]] and [[Eihwaz]].
Krahe treats ''ē₂'' (secondary ''ē'') as identical with ''ī''. It probably continues PIE ''ēi'', and it may have been in the process of transition from a diphthong to a long simple vowel in the Proto-Germanic period. Lehmann lists the following origins for ''ē₂'':<ref>{{cite web |url=http://www.utexas.edu/cola/centers/lrc/books/piep09.html | work=Proto-Indo-European phonology | title=The Origin of PGmc. Long Close e | first=Winfred P. | last=Lehmann | location=Austin | publisher=Linguistics Research Center | year=2007}}</ref>
* ''ēi'': Old High German ''fiara'', ''fera'' "ham", Goth ''fera'' "side, flank" ← PGmc *''fē₂rō'' ← *''pēi-s-eh₂'' ← PIE *''(s)peh₁i''-.
* The preterite of class VII strong verbs with ''ai'', ''al'' or ''an'' plus a consonant, or ''ē₁''.
* ''iz'': OEng ''mēd'', OHG ''miata'' "reward" (vs. OEng ''meord'', Goth ''mizdō'') ← PIE *''misdʰós''.
* Certain pronominal forms, e.&nbsp;g. OEng ''hēr'' "here".
* Words borrowed from Latin ''ē'' or ''e'' in the root syllable after a certain period (older loans also show ''ī'').
====Nasal vowels====
Proto-Germanic developed nasal vowels from two sources. The earlier and much more frequent source was word-final ''-n'' (from PIE ''-n'' or ''-m'') in unstressed syllables, which at first gave rise to short ''-ą'', ''-į'', ''-ų'', long ''-į̄'', ''-ę̄'', ''-ą̄'', and overlong ''-ę̂'', ''-ą̂''. ''-ę̄'' and ''-ę̂'' then merged into ''-ą̄'' and ''-ą̂'', which later developed into ''-ǭ'' and ''-ǫ̂''. Another source, developing only in late Proto-Germanic times, was in the sequences ''-inh-'', ''-anh-'', ''-unh-'', in which the nasal consonant lost its occlusion and was converted into lengthening and nasalisation of the preceding vowel, becoming ''-ą̄h-'', ''-į̄h-'', ''-ų̄h-'' (still written as ''-anh-'', ''-inh-'', ''-unh-'' in this article).
In many cases, the nasality was not contrastive and was merely present as an additional surface articulation. No Germanic language that preserves the word-final vowels has their nasality preserved. Word-final short nasal vowels do not show different reflexes compared to non-nasal vowels. However, the comparative method does require a three-way phonemic distinction between word-final ''*-ō'', ''*-ǭ'' and ''-ōn'', which each has a distinct pattern of reflexes in the later Germanic languages:
{| class="wikitable"
! Proto-Germanic
! Gothic
! Old Norse
! Old High German
! Old English
|-
| -ō
| -a
| -u > -
| -u / -
| -u / -
|-
| -ǭ
| -a
| -a
| -a
| -e
|-
| -ōn
| -ōn
| -a, -u
| -ōn
| -an
|}
The distinct reflexes of nasal ''-ǭ'' versus non-nasal ''-ō'' are caused by the Northwest Germanic raising of final ''-ō'' {{IPA|/ɔː/}} to {{IPA|/oː/}}, which did not affect ''-ǭ''. When the vowels were shortened and denasalised, these two vowels no longer had the same place of articulation, and did not merge: ''-ō'' became {{IPA|/o/}} (later {{IPA|/u/}}) while ''-ǭ'' became {{IPA|/ɔ/}} (later {{IPA|/ɑ/}}). This allowed their reflexes to stay distinct.
The nasality of word-internal vowels (from ''-nh-'') was more stable, and survived into the early dialects intact.
Phonemic nasal vowels definitely occurred in [[Proto-Norse]] and [[Old Norse]]. They were preserved in Old Icelandic down to at least 1125 AD, the earliest possible time for the creation of the [[First Grammatical Treatise]], which documents nasal vowels. The PG nasal vowels from ''-nh-'' sequences were preserved in Old Icelandic as shown by examples given in the First Grammatical Treatise. For example:
* ''há̇r'' "shark" < ''*hą̄haz'' < PG ''*hanhaz''
* ''ǿ̇ra'' "younger" < ''*jų̄hizô'' < PG ''*junhizô'' (cf. Gothic ''jūhiza'')
The phonemicity is evident from minimal pairs like ''ǿ̇ra'' "younger" vs. ''ǿra'' "vex" < ''*wor-'', cognate with English ''weary''.<ref>Einar Haugen, "First Grammatical Treatise. The Earliest Germanic Phonology", ''Language'', 26:4 (Oct - Dec, 1950), pp. 4-64 (p. 33).</ref> The inherited Proto-Germanic nasal vowels were joined in Old Norse by nasal vowels from other sources, e.g. loss of ''*n'' before ''s''. Modern [[Elfdalian]] still includes nasal vowels that directly derive from Old Norse, e.g. ''gą̊s'' "goose" < Old Norse ''gás'' (presumably nasalized, although not so written); cf. German ''Gans'', showing the original consonant.
Similar surface (possibly phonemic) nasal/non-nasal contrasts occurred in the West Germanic languages down through Proto-Anglo-Frisian of 400 AD or so. Proto-Germanic medial nasal vowels were inherited, but were joined by new nasal vowels resulting from the [[Ingvaeonic nasal spirant law]], which extended the loss of nasal consonants (only before ''-h-'' in Proto-Germanic) to all environments before a fricative (thus including ''-mf-'', ''-nþ-'' and ''-ns-'' as well). The contrast between nasal and non-nasal long vowels  is reflected in the differing output of nasalized long ''*ą̄'', which was raised to ''ō'' in Old English (modern ''oo'') whereas non-nasal ''*ā'' appeared as fronted ''ǣ''. Hence:
* ''goose'' < Old English ''gōs'' < Anglo-Frisian ''*gą̄s'' < Proto-Germanic ''[[wikt:Appendix:Proto-Germanic/gans|*gans]]''
* ''tooth'' < Old English ''tōþ'' < Anglo-Frisian ''*tą̄þ'' < Proto-Germanic ''[[wikt:Appendix:Proto-Germanic/tanþs|*tanþ-]]''
* ''brought'' < Old English ''brōhte'' < Anglo-Frisian ''*brą̄htæ'' < Proto-Germanic ''[[wikt:Appendix:Proto-Germanic/bringaną|*branhtē]]''.
<references/>
Retrieved from "https://linguifex.com/wiki/Special:MobileDiff/22488"