2,969
edits
Linguifex:Arbitration/Requests/Case: Difference between revisions
Jump to navigation
Jump to search
Linguifex:Arbitration/Requests/Case (view source)
Revision as of 20:52, 16 January 2013
, 16 January 2013→Statement by {Party 2}
Herr Dunkel (talk | contribs) |
|||
| Line 27: | Line 27: | ||
=== Statement by {Party 2} === | === Statement by {Party 2} === | ||
I my defence I wish to clearly state that no spite was ever intended. No indication of spite, ill faith or diminutivisation is apparent judging from my message, nor from previous conversations on this wiki with the claimant. | |||
In defence of retroactive application of the policy guidelines, with emphasis on guidelines, it ought to be clarified that the action was succeded by a civil message on the claimant's discussion page, and that the claimant received no repercussions of the claimed retroactive application of the policy guideline. As such no true application of the policy occurred. Instead, only revertion of the page blanking was performed, acting through the legitimacy of implied guidelines. Whilst not stated (by the time) in the policy, editing of other users' comments is and was severely discouraged. Whilst this may not be optimal, nor is the wiki. The Linguifex wiki is under construction, including policy guidelines. | |||
Per the claimant's logic, this would legitimise the violation of these implied guidelines if not expressed in writing, which would damage, inhibit and impede the continuation and construction of the wiki, thus legitimising the revertion. This concludes that the retroactive application of the G:9 paragraph in the Linguifex deletion policy acted as a reminder of written implementation, also explicating the lack of repercussions. | |||
In response to the similes of democratic law, there seems to be a need for clarification and definition to ease categorisation: | |||
*The Linguifex wiki is not a democratic nation. It lacks a constitution and legislature. | |||
**As such, the Linguifex wiki guidelines are not laws. | |||
**As such, enforcing wiki guidelines as law is inappropriate and exaggerative. | |||
As always, sincerely, [[File:Waahlis.png|35px|link=Linguifex:Administrators]] '''[[User talk:Waahlis|<span style="color: Orange;">Waahlis</span>]]''' 21:52, 16 January 2013 (CET) | |||
=== Statement by {Party 3} === | === Statement by {Party 3} === | ||